Re: Moscow Civic Association

["Melynda Huskey" <mghuskey@hotmail.com>]

 

Douglas Wilson writes:

 

"Does this progressive meeting of the Moscow Civic Association (to which
non-progressives need not come) have any agenda items with regard to the
government school system? In other words, should the government school
system be progressive too? If it should be, then it follows that we
non-progressives are uninvited to that worldview party as well. Which,
incidentally, is the point we trinitarians have been making . . ."

 

May I call your attention to the logical fallacy of Equivocation?  "Need not come" is not logically equivalent to "uninvited."  I also noted the reductio ad absurdam in the claim that inclusivity must be defined as always including everyone in every activity.

 

I don't think the discussion is likely to get anywhere in the near future.

 

Pedantically,

 

Melynda Huskey

---

Get more from the Web.  FREE MSN Explorer download : http://explorer.msn.com