vision2020
Shahab responding
- To: <vision2020@moscow.com>
- Subject: Shahab responding
- From: "Shahab Mesbah" <moscadmin@moscow.com>
- Date: Sun, 30 Jan 2000 14:09:25 -0800
- Reply-To: "Shahab Mesbah" <moscadmin@moscow.com>
- Resent-Date: Sun, 30 Jan 2000 14:13:10 -0800 (PST)
- Resent-From: vision2020@moscow.com
- Resent-Message-ID: <fsLRED.A.RvI.kdLl4@whale.fsr.net>
- Resent-Sender: vision2020-request@moscow.com
My beloved friends,
I am overwhelmed with the level of kindness... I
have to say I was blushing so intensely when I was reading your replies that
Hilary was wondering what was going on. I appreciate the concerted effort to
control the use of "abusive language" in this list. I do have a comment to make
on that topic.
I left my country in 1978 due to the fact that my
father was in the government and the religious fundamentalists (I use this term
as it is used colloquially in the US this is not an insult to our religious
friends) that were coming to power actively persecuted us due to our education,
religion, and the roll we played in the previous government. in fact I lost many
members of my family and dear friends to the completely man made dogma of a
group who use terror to control others in the name of God. the fact that they
have soiled the name of Mohammad and Islam who's message, as with Jesus and
Christianity, was peace and harmony can not be disputed.
When I arrived from Europe six months later in Jan.
of 1979 I was excited to be in the US to go to school and learn English.
unfortunately I learned that the same blind, illogical hatred existed in the US.
I was attacked by groups dressed in robes and several times cut up pretty good
too. I have been attacked by the KKK and the Arian-nation group up north. I have
seen the ugliness of ignorance and decided that I would rise above it. to rise
above this I knew I could not just do nothing; I could not just take abuse and
bear it; I could not allow it to go on.
One gift that we have in this country is the
democratic process. as we experienced this first hand last week and as some of
you so eloquently stated; I do not see any need for a policing of this forum
other than what happens naturally within the group. I think the group as a
dynamic and highly intelligent organism can judge better the individual cases
rather than rigid laws that may get in the way of our open
discussions.
As for the comment from PC... I have to say that
the only problem that I had with it was that it did not offer any useful
information. The message did not offer me any guidance for improving myself.
When I first got the message I really was not mad... I felt like I missed the
point that he was making; I felt that I was not allowed to understand his point
of view due to his anger... I felt a loss. I agree with the friend who stated
that paternal control of the group would be detrimental. I am glad the messages
have been coming in unedited! This way I can see what you really
think; this way I can respond so you better understand what I am trying to say
instead of what is coming out. I would like to know what made PC so angry... I
have been trying to make myself understood and have succeeded with many of you.
It appears that I have not clarified my motives to some of you. I would like to
further clarify a few points that have come up in your responses to
me.
Advertising: one of the friends correctly took
issue with the way I seem to have equated advertising with lying. we have
advertised through the time that the store was open but limited the
advertisements to information only. We have been underwriting the public radio
for many years, we have had large Yellow Pages advertisement until this year, we
have advertised on 106, have done some print advertisement, and we have
three signs in front of our store stating that we service and build computer
systems, and network solutions. We have shunned sensational advertising
which we find offensive. When I was talking about advertising I should have
said sensational advertising; this was my error and I apologize if I insulted
anyone in advertising. I do find it offensive when companies advertise a PC for
$200 and by the time you leave with one you have worked up to $1500! this
happens a lot and is false advertising in my opinion.
In business?: yes we (Hilary and I) are still in
business. We have been doing most of our work on-site for a long time and
finally realized that the store was dragging us down. We do everything we did
before except that now we do not have a store front. One of the friends had
suggested that we use this forum for promoting our business. My feeling on this
matter is clear: I find it unethical to promote ones business in a forum
who's purpose is non commercial social improvement. If you are interested in
contacting us in a commercial setting please feel free to contact us at meteor2@moscow.com I do appreciate your interest in us.
Local Business: I do not consider national chains
local business. I see them as funnels sucking money out of small communities so
a few people can get filthy rich. I believe that the large chain stores are
contributing to urban decay as well as social degradation. I also have a big
problem with malls. I know you think they are convenient but just look around
and see what they do to cities. We have two of them... they suck the life out of
cities unless they are properly designed. Look at what all the malls did to
Spokane so now they have to spend millions to make downtown vital again. The
money we save in discount stores, we pay ten times more in the long run in taxes
to revitalize our city. Why go through the cycle of decay and rebuild? Why not
just do a little every day so that problems are taken care of when they are
small. We were a member of the Moscow Chamber of Commerce the first year and did
not renew our membership due to this very issue. The Chamber does not
differentiate between local business and national chains. I find the
Chamber useless. I see the need to create a new organization that dedicates
itself in the interests of our city and not large business
interests.
Leave!: to the friend who suggested I leave if I do
not like the people here... do you think I would have given any of you any
thought if I did not care deeply about you? Do you think I would have invested
over $200K in this city if I did not care? Did your father not care about you
when he tried to point out faults that needed to be corrected? Do your friends
not help you become a better person? Why is it that we have such a hard time
with someone trying to help? Do we feel like they are showing off? I assure you
my intentions are quite the contrary. I see a wonderful city with marvelous
people I love you all dearly. Due to my deep love and conviction I find it
necessary to try to improve things... it is in my nature... I have to improve
everything! I have redesigned everything I have come to contact with! I hope
this is clear since everything else depends on your understanding of my
motivation.
back on soap!: let us not just talk about this...
let us make OUR city a city to be an example to all cities. Let us get together
and achieve unity in our diversity. We have the power to create a society here
that would set examples for the future of our world. We have to stop just
talking and have to act. We have to be kind and loving to one another. Let us
meet!! One of the difficulties of having the store was the 100 hours a week I
had to work. I did not have much time. It would be my honor to meet with you in
a regularly scheduled open forum of discussion. We should just get to know one
another and then be more comfortable with where each one of us is coming from.
We could arrange for block parties to get the neighborhoods talking and maybe...
just maybe when we talk we would realize that the problems are not that big. We
are many and together we can overcome difficulties much greater than what we
have to deal with today. We could involve the thousands of people who we never
hear from in our town. Many individuals never realize that there are a thousand
people with the same issues and ideas that they have. We feel isolated and alone
and this causes inactivity and lack of involvement. If we want a vibrant society
we must actively participate in our community. One of the reasons behind closing
the store for me was greater involvement in my city. I hope that together we can
find the time and the energy to get together and become a close community again.
Many of you reminisce about the friendly old days... well these are our days,
this is our city, this is our society, and we have the power to make them what
we choose.
I will leave you with the following quote... I hope
you find it as enlightening as I did:
"OF MAN OF TWO VISIONS! Close one eye and open the
other. Close one to the world and all that is therein, and open the other
to the hallowed beauty of the Beloved."
your brother in arms,
Shahab...
Shahab Mesbah
Back to TOC