vision2020@moscow.com: 2/23 article titled "Recycling proposal is a new idea for Idaho"

2/23 article titled "Recycling proposal is a new idea for Idaho"

Tom and Briana LeClaire (bri-tom@moscow.com)
Tue, 24 Feb 98 15:08:08 PST

Let me see if I have this straight: the Daily News thinks it won't cost
any more for local and state governments to use recycled, instead of
virgin, paper if the Idaho Legislature signs off on a ten percent
purchasing preference, as advocated by Moscow Recycling and a graduate
student. HUH?!?

Our local members of the fourth estate must have failed Economics 101,
because a ten percent purchasing preference means, in plain English,
goverment agencies within Idaho will be allowed to spend up to ten percent
MORE of our hard-earned tax dollars on paper, as long as it's recycled.
What a great idea -- NOT!

Did it ever occur to anyone why virgin paper is less expensive than
recycled? It's because recycling paper is like recycling sand. If my
toddler decides she wants a sandbox this summer, after I can't talk her out
of it I'll head to a nursery and buy some sand. I will NOT go to East City
Park and pick up the individual granules that have been cast aside by
enthusiastic sand-castle builders. Why will I not do this? Because sand
is cheap and the time required for the labor-intensive sand-recycling task
isn't worth my while. Guess what? Recycled paper isn't worth our while,
either! There never was and never will be a virgin paper shortage.

Although I grow weary from pointing it out so frequently, I must add that
Relene Johnson of Moscow Recycling is completely wrong when she says leaky
(error #1) landfill space is filling up (error #2). But I suppose
fact-finding would be asking too much from the Daily News, especially when
writing about the recycling religion.

Before anyone writes this page to excoriate me for my heresy, read "What A
Waste" in the June 30, 1996 New York Times Magazine. I myself am going to
thank my lucky stars for our neighbors in southern Idaho who have no doubt
elected legislators who will kill this extremely stupid bill.

Sincerely,

Briana LeClaire


This archive courtesy of:
First Step Internet

This archive courtesy of:
First Step Internet